Steve Nicol Makes Bold Mohamed Salah Claim That Will Split Liverpool Fans’ Opinions

Steve Nicol Makes Bold Mohamed Salah Claim That Will Split Liverpool Fans’ Opinions

Liverpool legend Steve Nicol has sparked major debate among supporters after making a bold claim about Mohamed Salah’s long-term future at Anfield.

Speaking on ESPN FC, Nicol questioned whether Liverpool should continue to build their attack around the 32-year-old winger, suggesting the club may soon need to make a “big, uncomfortable decision” about their star forward. According to the former Reds defender, Liverpool’s recent struggles highlight “a team too dependent on Salah,” and he believes the club must start planning for a future without him at the centre of everything.

Nicol argued that while Salah remains one of the Premier League’s most feared attackers, the team’s overall style of play has shifted, and the Egyptian’s influence is not as consistently decisive as it once was. He added that Liverpool should not shy away from considering a major rebuild—one that could involve cashing in on Salah before his contract situation becomes an issue.

His comments immediately divided fans online. Some supporters agreed, insisting that Liverpool cannot rely on Salah forever and that the squad needs fresh leadership in attack. Others called Nicol’s verdict “reactionary,” pointing out that Salah is still among the league’s top performers and remains the club’s most reliable source of goals.

The debate comes at a time when Liverpool are facing questions over form, squad depth, and the direction of Arne Slot’s project. With Salah’s contract running down and interest from Saudi Arabia expected to re-emerge, Nicol’s comments have only intensified discussion about what comes next for Liverpool’s talisman.

Whether or not Liverpool actually consider a future without Salah, Nicol’s bold assessment has undeniably split opinion—yet again proving just how important and divisive the Egyptian King remains at Anfield.