Tottenham Edge Past Manchester United 4-3 to Set Up Carabao Cup Semi-Final Against Liverpool
Tottenham secured a thrilling 4-3 victory over Manchester United in the Carabao Cup quarter-finals, setting up a semi-final clash with Liverpool. The match was dominated by goalkeeping errors and defensive mishaps, making for a dramatic encounter. However, it was Son Heung-min’s controversial late winner that sparked significant debate, with rules expert Christina Unkel providing insight into why the goal was allowed to stand.
In the 88th minute, Son scored directly from a corner after United goalkeeper Altay Bayindir misjudged the ball, missing an attempted punch as it floated over him and into the net. Initial replays suggested the goal resulted from Bayindir’s error, but further footage revealed substitute Lucas Bergvall making contact with Bayindir by placing an arm on him, prompting outrage from Manchester United fans. However, without VAR—implemented only in the semi-finals—the goal stood, leaving United unable to challenge the decision.
United tried to mount a late comeback, with Jonny Evans scoring in added time to reduce the deficit, but the goal was little more than a consolation as Tottenham held on for the win.
Rules Expert Explains Decision
Speaking on CBS Sports after the game, former FIFA referee Christina Unkel explained why Son’s goal was not disallowed. “Do we want this decision to be called a foul on the pitch? The answer is yes,” she stated. “If VAR had been available, we could debate whether it was clear and obvious. But from the referee’s position, looking through a crowd of players, it may have been difficult to fully assess the level of contact.”
Unkel further clarified: “This is what we would consider a simple foul, but it doesn’t rise to the level of a clear and obvious error. Therefore, the referee’s decision to allow the goal stands.”
When asked if VAR would have helped referee John Brooks make a different call, she replied, “No. Every goal is checked, whether it’s given or not. The referee must still make the decisions he believes are correct.”
Focus Shifts Back to Premier League Action
Both teams have endured inconsistent seasons, experiencing a mix of highs and lows. As the focus returns to the Premier League, Manchester United will host Bournemouth on Sunday, while Tottenham, buoyed by their dramatic win, will face league leaders Liverpool.
Leave a Reply