12 Most Disappointing Premier League Players of the 2024/25 Season [Ranked]
The Premier League is known for its unpredictability, where moments of brilliance are often contrasted by players who fail to deliver. Some struggle due to a lack of confidence, while others simply can’t adapt, regardless of their experience or the club they represent. This includes both newcomers and seasoned players from clubs like Arsenal, Manchester City, and Liverpool, who sometimes fail to meet expectations.
Ranking Criteria:
The following players have been ranked based on these factors:
Goals
Assists
Clean sheets
Pre-season expectations
Individual performances
Contributions to team success
—
1. Kyle Walker (Manchester City)
One of the Premier League’s finest right-backs, Walker’s age (34) is catching up to him. His declining mobility has seen Pep Guardiola lean more on younger talents like Rico Lewis. Once a cornerstone of City’s defense, Walker’s performances have dipped significantly, making him a potential transfer candidate after a difficult start to the season.
—
2. Joshua Zirkzee (Manchester United)
Signed for £36.5 million, Zirkzee was expected to complement Manchester United’s attack rather than be a prolific scorer. Despite a debut goal, his performances have fallen short, and the former Bayern Munich prospect has yet to prove his worth at Old Trafford.
—
3. Phil Foden (Manchester City)
Last season’s Player of the Year, Foden has seen a sharp decline in form due to injuries and inconsistent performances. Despite being part of most matchday squads, his output (one goal and one assist) is far below expectations. However, he’s slowly working his way back into Guardiola’s plans.
—
4. Jack Grealish (Manchester City)
Since his £100 million move from Aston Villa, Grealish has struggled to justify his price tag, with modest contributions of 14 goals and 20 assists over three seasons. While his off-the-ball work is appreciated, fans expect more from the highly-touted winger, who now faces questions about his future at the club.
—
5. Bruno Fernandes (Manchester United)
Bruno has been a pivotal figure for United in recent years, but this season has been disappointing. Despite being a goal-scoring midfielder, his contributions have dwindled. His erratic performances, combined with petulance and three red cards, have started to test the patience of fans.
—
6. Marcus Rashford (Manchester United)
A product of United’s academy, Rashford’s four goals and one assist in 15 games this season are underwhelming. With his poor work ethic and a desire for a “new challenge,” Rashford’s time at Old Trafford could be nearing an end.
—
7. Ederson (Manchester City)
Renowned for his ball-playing skills, Ederson has struggled this season, conceding 19 goals in 13 games while keeping only two clean sheets. Though City’s defensive issues contribute, his form suggests he may no longer be at his peak.
—
8. Gabriel Martinelli (Arsenal)
After a stellar 2022/23 season, Martinelli has failed to replicate his success, with only four goals and two assists so far. Often replaced by Leandro Trossard or Raheem Sterling, the Brazilian winger has lost his spark under Mikel Arteta.
—
9. Andrew Robertson (Liverpool)
Robertson, a consistent performer for Liverpool in the past, has struggled in Arne Slot’s system. His trademark pinpoint deliveries have diminished, prompting the club to scout potential replacements like Antonee Robinson from Fulham.
—
10. Matthijs de Ligt (Manchester United)
Despite high expectations due to his past success with Erik ten Hag at Ajax, De Ligt has struggled to adapt to the Premier League. While he has shown glimpses of quality, the Dutch defender has yet to fully justify his summer transfer to Manchester United.
Leave a Reply